Strain localisation is a key predisposing factor for frictional instability and earthquake nucleation. Experimental studies demonstrate that increasing localisation promotes unstable slip behaviour (Marone & Kilgore, 1993) and high localisation is also associated with natural earthquake occurrence (e.g., pseudotachylyte and fault mirrors). However, localisation stems from mechanisms that are inherently different depending on the investigated scale. Earthquake nucleation first occurs at the grain-scale, where the number and hierarchy of factors controlling strain localisation remains poorly constrained. In this study, we use field investigation, laboratory experiments, and microstructural analysis to understand the emergence of instability and localisation in carbonate rocks. Carbonate rocks represent interesting materials in this context because of their presence in several seismogenic terrains (sedimentary sequences) and their non-trivial mechanical behaviour. Indeed, pure calcite microgranular powder obtained by crushing and sieving Carrara marble exhibits stable behaviour, whereas bare rock surfaces of limestone promote instability (Carpenter et al., 2014). This is related to the fact rock surfaces impose preferred pathways for strain localisation at the onset of slip, thus promoting unstable sliding. Curiously, pure calcite nanogranular gouges (1-2 orders of magnitude smaller than the microgranular powder) also promote unstable behaviour. We then infer that the similarity between bare rock surfaces and nanogouge might be, again, related to a matter of efficient localisation of strain. If so, then even in nominally homogeneous materials, geometric and fabric-related factors alone may exert a primary control on carbonate stability. Comparative microstructural observations on field-derived natural samples of Carrara marble (large-grained carbonate) and Maiolica micrites (fine-grained carbonate) reveal evident differences in the geometry and arrangement of microfractures, suggesting different deformation dynamics for the two cases. Microfracture propagation appears controlled by the twinning activity, grain-boundary geometry, cleavage orientation, and porosity distribution. At the same time, field-scale observations in the origin terrains reveal differences in the modality of faulting. Carrara marbles host sharp and highly localised faults, while micrites develop distributed fracture networks. The ultimate objective of this work is to establish a scale-dependent framework for the interpretation and quantification of factors that control strain localisation in carbonate rocks, aiming also at assessing their relevance across scales when bridging laboratory and field observations.

Microscale controls on efficient early strain localisation in carbonate rocks

Cantelli Marta;Tesei Telemaco;Pozzi Giacomo
2026

Abstract

Strain localisation is a key predisposing factor for frictional instability and earthquake nucleation. Experimental studies demonstrate that increasing localisation promotes unstable slip behaviour (Marone & Kilgore, 1993) and high localisation is also associated with natural earthquake occurrence (e.g., pseudotachylyte and fault mirrors). However, localisation stems from mechanisms that are inherently different depending on the investigated scale. Earthquake nucleation first occurs at the grain-scale, where the number and hierarchy of factors controlling strain localisation remains poorly constrained. In this study, we use field investigation, laboratory experiments, and microstructural analysis to understand the emergence of instability and localisation in carbonate rocks. Carbonate rocks represent interesting materials in this context because of their presence in several seismogenic terrains (sedimentary sequences) and their non-trivial mechanical behaviour. Indeed, pure calcite microgranular powder obtained by crushing and sieving Carrara marble exhibits stable behaviour, whereas bare rock surfaces of limestone promote instability (Carpenter et al., 2014). This is related to the fact rock surfaces impose preferred pathways for strain localisation at the onset of slip, thus promoting unstable sliding. Curiously, pure calcite nanogranular gouges (1-2 orders of magnitude smaller than the microgranular powder) also promote unstable behaviour. We then infer that the similarity between bare rock surfaces and nanogouge might be, again, related to a matter of efficient localisation of strain. If so, then even in nominally homogeneous materials, geometric and fabric-related factors alone may exert a primary control on carbonate stability. Comparative microstructural observations on field-derived natural samples of Carrara marble (large-grained carbonate) and Maiolica micrites (fine-grained carbonate) reveal evident differences in the geometry and arrangement of microfractures, suggesting different deformation dynamics for the two cases. Microfracture propagation appears controlled by the twinning activity, grain-boundary geometry, cleavage orientation, and porosity distribution. At the same time, field-scale observations in the origin terrains reveal differences in the modality of faulting. Carrara marbles host sharp and highly localised faults, while micrites develop distributed fracture networks. The ultimate objective of this work is to establish a scale-dependent framework for the interpretation and quantification of factors that control strain localisation in carbonate rocks, aiming also at assessing their relevance across scales when bridging laboratory and field observations.
2026
Abstract Book del Congresso Congiunto SGI-SIMP 2026
File in questo prodotto:
Non ci sono file associati a questo prodotto.
Pubblicazioni consigliate

I documenti in IRIS sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.

Utilizza questo identificativo per citare o creare un link a questo documento: https://hdl.handle.net/11577/3623998
Citazioni
  • ???jsp.display-item.citation.pmc??? ND
  • Scopus ND
  • ???jsp.display-item.citation.isi??? ND
  • OpenAlex ND
social impact