The paper builds upon the CJUE’s ruling in Mousse v CNIL and SNFC Connect of January 9, 2025. In it, the Court addresses the question of collecting personal data that reveals gender identity in light of the principle of data minimisation. The essay focuses on two critical parts of the decision, outlining the strengths and weaknesses of the current scope and implementation of the minimisation principle in European private law. First, it examines the Court's established case law on the lawfulness of data processing without the data subject's consent, with a focus on the legal bases of contract performance and the legitimate interest pursued by the controller. To this aim, it also considers the Meta Platforms Inc v Bundeskartellamt case of July 4, 2023. Second, it evaluates the adequacy and relevance of collecting gender identity data, such as the titles "Mr." or "Mrs.", in commercial forms. To that purpose, the Court's decision is reviewed in light of a comparative study of the Italian and German legal systems, where the question of processing data that qualify as gender-specific has been addressed by case law and data protection authorities.
Il principio di minimizzazione dei dati: una recente decisione della Corte di giustizia
Giulia Binato
2026
Abstract
The paper builds upon the CJUE’s ruling in Mousse v CNIL and SNFC Connect of January 9, 2025. In it, the Court addresses the question of collecting personal data that reveals gender identity in light of the principle of data minimisation. The essay focuses on two critical parts of the decision, outlining the strengths and weaknesses of the current scope and implementation of the minimisation principle in European private law. First, it examines the Court's established case law on the lawfulness of data processing without the data subject's consent, with a focus on the legal bases of contract performance and the legitimate interest pursued by the controller. To this aim, it also considers the Meta Platforms Inc v Bundeskartellamt case of July 4, 2023. Second, it evaluates the adequacy and relevance of collecting gender identity data, such as the titles "Mr." or "Mrs.", in commercial forms. To that purpose, the Court's decision is reviewed in light of a comparative study of the Italian and German legal systems, where the question of processing data that qualify as gender-specific has been addressed by case law and data protection authorities.Pubblicazioni consigliate
I documenti in IRIS sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.




