Understanding Stabilization Factors in Heterodinuclear Ln–Al Complexes from DFT Simulations on Thermochemistry Data: A Counterintuitive Conclusion

This study validates a computational protocol to predict the stability of heterodinuclear complexes by varying ligands on both moieties and analyzing the reaction Gibbs free energy (Delta G (R)) values. To this purpose, a series of Eu-Al complexes with the general formula [Eu(L-Eu)(3)Al(L-Al)(3)], where L-Eu is the ligand of europium and L-Al is an oxygen donor ligand of aluminum, is used. The nature of the bridging bonds and thermochemical characteristics (Delta G (R), enthalpy, and entropy) of the complexes were evaluated via DFT calculations. We demonstrated that both entropic and enthalpic effects play a relevant role in the stability. The analysis of the series allows us to identify three Delta G (R) ranges where heterodinuclear complexes are (i) stable and easy to characterize, (ii) fragile and difficult to characterize, and (iii) not observed (unreacted precursors are recovered). To rationalize the trend of the stability and correlate it with the chemical nature of the ligands, we investigated the condensed Fukui function on the Al fragment. Results suggest that to obtain stable heteronuclear complexes, it is necessary to consider ligands with small condensed Fukui function values. This corresponds to a less nucleophilic oxygen site, yet counterintuitively, it allows the ligand to delocalize the received electronic charge and stabilize the complex.